what
Upload your finished jpeg before the end of Sunday September 5 at
www.istockbattleroyale.com.
Please note that clicking this link will take you to away from iStockphoto.com. We are using a third-party site called Strutta.com to host the Qualifying round. You will be asked to register all this requires is a name and email address.
Haw haw
+
Execution: The technical meat & potatoes of your blow: the isolation work, lighting, layering, and use of effects.
Poor: You used the magic wand tool, didn't you?
Needs Work: Edges are jagged or fuzzy where they shouldn't be. Effects aren't uniformly applied and we can see where the layers meet. You need to take more time on the details and work on your Photoshop skills.
Average: There may be inconsistencies in where the light comes from. Isolation and masking work could be better. The use of transparencies and layer effects is a little obvious and could be better integrated. But all in all, not bad.
Very Good: You've attempted some difficult isolation and effects, and for the most part made them work. Any complaints are minor well done.
Perfect: A photo-realistic, seamless effort. The viewer has no idea how you pulled this off.
---------------------------------------------------------------------
In my experience from iStock they reject my isolations are mostly under "Needs Work" as nonexclusive while beardless kids from school grabbing money from them in explanation how site is horizontal and "will be priceless better (for they pocket) if it will bee vertical"
Anyhow I dont want play this iStock peewee game... ad that is 1/4 reasons why.
I just cant imagine sadomazohistic combination of rejections which are mentioned below
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Composition: The artistic strength of your blow: your use of space within the confines of the image dimensions, the unity of your colors, lines and shapes, and the immediate visual impact of the blow.
Poor: Sorry, but did you look at this before uploading it?
Needs Work: There's nothing visually exciting or distinctive about this blow. Your layout, your color choices, your tone, all need more time and care.
Average: You've used the canvas well. Things are well laid out but not necessarily striking.
Very Good: This is a good-looking blow. Nice design choices, strong color, and a really clear visual identity.
Perfect: A work of art. Whether it's the intricacy of the elements, or the sheer boldness of the design, it's a thing of beauty.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Use of Elements: How well did you incorporate the existing elements from the previous blow?
Poor: A complete wipe. No effort to use any previous elements.
Needs Work: We can recognize elements from the previous blow, but things might be a bit clumsy, or poorly integrated.
Average: Visible elements are well-integrated, but nothing really stands out in the way you've used them.
Very Good: Not only are the elements there, but you've established some continuity with what happened before: we've got a narrative now between the two.
Perfect: You've not only cleverly manipulated the main elements into a completely new concept, you've created some narrative continuity and found neat ways to work in radical alterations as well as minor details
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originality & Creativity: Did you re-hash a haggard old cage concept, or are you showing us something we've never seen before?
Poor: You took the original blow and put it in a picture frame. Boo.
Needs Work: You've moved the elements around but without any real sense of why. None of the elements add up to something new or innovative.
Average: Your science-fiction space battle is pretty good, but we get a lot of science-fiction space battles around here.
Very Good: ... We get relatively few science-fiction Prom-dances though. Nice work on the martian spiking the punch.
Perfect: We thought we'd seen it all, then we saw this. Outstanding.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
from many aspects of view it is just PITA